Skeleton Argument Nicholas Gilodi-Johnson Farepak Food & Gifts Limited

Nicholas Gilodi-Johnson Skeleton Argument



Mr Gilodi-Johnson is the only son of Bob Johnson, one of the founders of Farepak. In 1993, its shares were listed on the London Stock Exchange. The listed company was Farepak plc. It subsequently changed its name to Kleeneze plc and then to the European Home Retail plc (“EHR”) in 2005. The original Farepak business at this time was carried on by a subsidiary known as Farepak Food and Gifts Ltd (“FFG”).


Wednesday, 30 May 2012
At 10 o’clock
HC12A01404 Quayle v Rothman Pantail & Co
Not Before half past 10
Part Heard
584 of 2011 In the matter of European Home Retail plc and in the matter of Farepak Food & Gifts Ltd


As advised by Unfairpak, the trial is set down for 6 to 8 weeks.

It got off to a slow start today, 24 May 2012, with the Secretary of State giving opening submissions before Mr Justice Peter Smith and advising him that he had the power to disqualify them from being directors from between 2 to 15 years.

In written submissions, Malcolm Davis-White QC, acting on behalf of the Insolvency Service stated “The proceedings, seeking disqualification orders, are brought against directors of the holding company European Home Retail and its subsidiary Farepak Food & Gifts. They concern approximately the last year or so of trading of Farepak and the group.”  Mr Justice Peter Smith was also told that the directors had traded at an “unreasonable risk” and that the collapse of Farepak Food & Gifts Limited had not came “out of the blue”.

Accordingly, the Insolvency Service are making “allegations of unfit conduct” and are arguing that the directors of European Home Retail (hereainafter referred to as “EHR”) or Farepak Food & Gifts Limited allowed or caused said companies to “trade at the unreasonable risk of its creditors”.

As Unfairpak exclusively revealed to the Sunday Herald on 12 February 2012, two former directors of Farepak Food & Gifts Limited have already taken voluntary disqualification.  Joanne Ponting and Stephen Hicks both took voluntary disqualification in 2011.

Michael Johns who was a non executive director at the time of the collapse is a senior partner with the London firm K&L Gates and is being represented by said company.  Neil Gillis and Paul Munn, Farepak directors and Sir Clive Thompson, former chairman are also being represented by said firm with Paul Girolami QC of Maitland Chambers instructed as counsel.

Richard Highley dispute resolution partner of DAC Beachcroft is acting for William Rollason and Steven Fowler with Michael Green QC of Fountain Court alongside.

The commercial dispute resolution partner of Nabarro has instructed Philip Jones QC of Serle Chambers to act for Nicholas Gilodi-Johnson, Farepak Food & Gifts Limited’s former managing director.

Lawyers for the Insolvency Service also pointed out that prior to the collapse on Friday 13 October 2006, “about £1 million a week” was coming in from Farepak savers who had “no inkling” of “any serious risk”.

Mr Davis-White also pointed out that company financial forecasts in November 2005 “identified a risk” that Farepak Food & Gifts Limited would not have enough monies to pay Choice Gift Vouchers, their main supplier.  Choice Gift Vouchers Limited entered administration on Tuesday 31 January 2006 having being paid approximately half of the £12.1 million owed to them by Farepak Food & Gifts Limited.

“With alarming cashflow projections available from early April 2006 warning of a lack of sufficient cash in the group from October 2006 onwards, various unsuccessful attempts were made by the group to find a solution to the funding crisis,” Mr Davis-White added.

“Throughout this period, savers’ weekly payments (amounting by October to some £2million per week) continued to be collected by Farepak and swept up daily into the group account, unprotected by any trust account or similar arrangement.”

“By the time Farepak ceased to accept savers’ money on October 11 2006, it had ordered no vouchers for Christmas 2006. On October 13 2006 European Home Retail and a number of its subsidiaries including Farepak entered (variously) administration and administrative receivership.”

Mr Davis-White also went on to point out that Farepak’s creditors were also savers.  He further went on to state that “we say you have to look at the overall financial position and the risk.  We say it is relevant that your creditors are savers. It should help you shape more carefully how you deal with things. It is all very well saying ‘they are creditors like any other’ but, in our respectful submission, they are not simply creditors like any other.”

Counsel will deliver opening submissions on behalf of the defendants tomorrow, 25 May 2012 and the court will begin hearing evidence on Monday, 28 May 2012.





In response to the various emails enquiring whether directors of companies can become company secretaries if they are disqualified, the facts are as follows.

From 6 April 2008 private limited companies have the right to choose whether or not they wish to have a company secretary.  If they already have a company secretary and wish to dispense with same, they need to inform Companies House.  Any company setting up business after 6 April 2008 can decide whether or not they wish a company secretary.

For the avoidance of doubt, a Public Limited Company MUST have a company secretary.

If a company chooses to have a secretary, the secretary basically deals with administrative procedures leaving the directors to run the company business.  Under the Companies Act 2006 there are no specific duties set down for company secretaries as these will usually be contained in a employment contract.  However, a company secretary, if appointed, will usually undertake the following duties; (1) maintaining the statutory registers which are; (i) the register of members; (ii) the register of directors and secretaries; (iii) the register of directors’ interests; (iv) the register of charges; and (v) for public companies only, the register of interests in shares.  The company secretary again, if appointed, will also be responsible for ensuring statutory forms are filed properly, providing member and auditors with notice of meetings, sending Companies House copies of resolutions and agreements, keeping minutes of directors meetings and general meetings and ensuring that people who are entitled to do so, can inspect company records.

If there is not a company secretary appointed, the aforementioned duties must still be carried out by either a director or someone authorised by a director to do same.

As you can see from the above, a company secretary albeit an important job, is an administrative role.  A disqualified director may become a company secretary but if he/she were found to be acting in anyway in the management of the company, he/she would then be committing a criminal offence and could face a jail period of up to 2 years as well as a fine and further disqualification period.

If anyone requires any further information, please do not hesitate to add your comments below.